Is the movie king's speech historically accurate

How historically accurate is the movie the kings speech. Amid colin firth s terrific performance as bertie, the duke of york he picked up britain s oscar equivalent, a bafta, earlier this month and the movie also won best picture then there were hints that the film was not true to life. You can explore the movie on a timeline, and ratings such as true or trueish as well as false or falseish tell you how accurate a given scene is. Colin firth makes an excellent king george vi so excellent, in fact, that he earned himself an oscar nomination for best actor. In a critically and commercially disappointing year for the film industry, one of the few highlights has been the reception given to the. How historically accurate was the kings speech 2010. The problem, however, is that the great bard himself took some creative liberties while writing them. So thank heavens for the the king s speech, says keith austin, who, like george vi. There is a reason that this movie, starring colin firth and geoffrey rush, received four oscar awards and was nominated for another eight 1. Principal among the movies gross inaccuracies is the portrayal of british soldiers as evil, bloodthirsty sadists. People can say, for example, that churchill didnt play nearly as big a role as he does in the film he wasnt actually there at such and such a point, he never uttered those words, and so on.

The story of king george vi, his impromptu ascension to the throne of the british empire in 1936, and the speech therapist who helped the unsure monarch overcome his stammer. Author peter conradi says the relationship between king. Its also an extremely historically inaccurate film, but that doesnt devalue it as a cinematic achievement. The kings speech seems to be the front runner to win the academy award for best picture tonight. Oct 22, 2016 one of the best movies that i have watched recently. Feb 27, 2011 the kings speech seems to be the front runner to win the academy award for best picture tonight. Ah yes, the oscar battle kings speech will win because its a more traditional oscar type of movie but i personally pick social network. Just started watching this show after watching the kings speech, and i was surprised that the king isnt stammering. The kings speech is headed for oscar glory but some have criticized its faulty history. Jan 26, 2011 but that doesnt make the kings speech a historically accurate film. The kings speech is an ugly distortion of history the new republic. Author peter conradi says the relationship between king george vi and his speech therapist was unusually.

With many of the events added for entertainment value it is still a wonderfully british drama, which touches on themes of friendship, love and overcoming the odds. Hugo vickers, royal adviser on the film the king s speech. The other part of the story, which is historically accurate, is that the kings wife, elizabeth, consistently encouraged him to seek help and to believe in himself. We asked a shakespeare scholar to factcheck the king. It was indeed hard to understand churchill until you got used to how he spoke, and even harder over the sound of the typewriter. The kings speech 412 movie clip night cap 2010 hd duration.

It s based on the true story of george vi, the father of the present queen of england. Only i was surprised the speech wasnt in the movie in. The kings speech cleaned up at the oscars, garnering statuettes for best film, best directing, best original screenplay and lead actor. Why it doesnt matter if the kings speech is historically.

As far as my moviegoing experience, the kings speech was so impressive that i can overlook the egregious inaccuracies and tired old myths. With 12 oscar nominations, the king s speech is among the most nominated films of all time. Yes, i know the likelihoods of movies being accurate are slim but the kings speech counts. The kings speech is an ugly distortion of history the.

Obviously, the dialogue was composed but the basic facts were largely true. With colin firth playing a royal with a stutter, the king s speech is certain for oscar magic, but andrew roberts says it gets the story all wrong and. For example, shakespeares julius caesar isnt exactly historically accurate i. Jan 09, 2011 how historically accurate is the king s speech. While historical dramas do a good job making audiences think about history, they are not usually accurate. A sickly youth, he had been happy to languish in the shadow of his older, mo. The kings speech is about prince albert who later became george vii he was not expecting to be king he was second in line to the throne but his brother abdicated the throne in order to marry an american divorcee that he.

The kings speech 2010 rotten tomatoes movie trailers. I know it is all in the interest of making the film historically accurate but it is out of line with what george is going through in the progression of his story. In the king s speech, cinema continues its love affair with the uptight brit, a stereotype that is out of. Braveheart the 10 historical inaccuracies you need to. The film tells the story of king george vi colin firth and his battle with a speech impediment. Milchs attempt to capture a sense of historical distance with the speech patterns of deadwood succeeds marvelously, but not because the dialogue achieves true realism or gritty accuracy. A few examples are seen in the kings speech 2010, argo 2012, selma 2014, and the recently premiered black klansman 2018 and green book 2018. The movie helped to inspire scottish national pride while also, to some, represent an early, medieval warrior who fought for freedom for himself and his people.

The film starring the ever charming george vi played by colin firth. Sure, some parts might be embellished like the scene between logue and bertie in westminster abbey, but the movie is a smidge too. As a specialist in british history, i agree that screenwriter david seidler certainly has tweaked the record a bit and telescoped events in the. Star and director mel gibson himself notes that the film is a historical.

The kings speech top 10 historically misleading films. As christopher hitchens points out in slate, winston churchill was a close friend and supporter of nazisympathizer king edward viii george vis brother, who abdicated the throne in order. Colin firth, following up on his oscarnominated role in a single man, now can claim a place among britain s finest film actors with his performance as the man who became king george vi. But i do admit that kings speech made me feel good. The kings speech is about prince albert who later became george vii he was not expecting to be king he was second in line to the throne but his brother abdicated the throne in order to marry an american divorcee that he had. I will start by saying that the kings speech is an exceptional movie. On the heels of its 12 academy award nominations, the kings speech, an inspiring story of king george vi and his triumph over stuttering, is being criticized for historical inaccuracies. Colin firth, following up on his oscarnominated role in a single man, now can claim a place among britains finest film actors with his performance as the man who became king george vi. But that doesnt make the kings speech a historically accurate film. The kings speech is an excellent film, but it does take a few pointless liberties with historical accuracy. The best part of the movie is that you can relate to your self in many ways. Hugo vickers, royal adviser on the film the kings speech my view is that a film is a film, and you have to move the drama on. Jan 06, 2011 but, unlike the queen, which was merely simplistic in its portrayal of the monarchy, the kings speech is historically inaccurate, entirely misleading, and, in its own small way, morally dubious. It may not be historically accurate but it s a damn enjoyable story told in an enjoyable way.

One of the best movies that i have watched recently. The kings speech i enjoyed this film and i would recommend it. How accurate is the portrayal of king george, more. I highly recommend that you take the opportunity to watch this film. Jan 24, 2011 the kings speech is an extremely wellmade film with a seductive human interest plot, very prettily calculated to appeal to the smarter filmgoer and the latent anglophile. Its her first day working for him and his harshness scares her off. Author peter conradi says the relationship between king george. Feb 23, 2011 ah yes, the oscar battle king s speech will win because it s a more traditional oscar type of movie but i personally pick social network. Looking back to a time that didnt quite exist the kings speech is an excellent film, but it does take a few pointless liberties with historical accuracy michael white.

Dec 05, 2011 the 1995 movie, braveheart, is a cinematic masterpiece. The men become friends as they work together, and after his brother abdicates the throne, the new king relies on logue to help him. How historically accurate was the kings speech 2010 movie. Just started watching this show after watching the kings speech, and i. I took the opportunity to see this movie in theaters when it first came out, in 2010. The kings speech told an important story, was historically accurate and showed one mans journey to deal with a serious stuttering problem and improve himself. The premise behind the king s speech is a rather dry one and the trailers themselves make it seem to be a cross between the madness of king george and pygmalion, but thanks to some winning. Its based on the true story of george vi, the father of the present queen of england. Sure, some parts might be embellished like the scene between logue and bertie in westminster abbey, but the movie is a smidge too close to historical fact to count as historical fiction. With colin firth playing a royal with a stutter, the kings speech is certain for oscar magic, but andrew roberts says it gets the story all wrong and. The film is loosely adapted from shakespeares plays henry iv, part 1, henry iv, part 2, and henry v. It may not be historically accurate but its a damn enjoyable story told in an enjoyable way.

Royal wedding watch how accurate was the kings speech. This website shows spotlight accuracy along with other. How historically accurate is netflixs new shakespearean drama. The king s speech flies the flag for a stiff upper lip that no longer exists david cox. It was historically accurate but colin firths excellent portrayal of george vii was marred only by the fact that he didnt really look like bertie. While much of the story depicted did occur, including the english occupation of scotland during the time of edward i, king of england, the depiction of the revolt against the english. With 12 oscar nominations, the kings speech is among the most nominated films of all time. A multiple oscar winner, an aweinspiring cinematic portrayal of scottish freedom fighter william wallace and his greatest accomplishments.

In one scene, redcoats are seen rounding up a village of screaming women, children and old men, locking them in a church and setting the building ablaze. The britishborn writer christopher hitchens, unsparing and. The kings speech is an extremely wellmade film with a seductive human interest plot, very prettily calculated to appeal to the smarter filmgoer and the latent anglophile. With colin firth playing a royal with a stutter, the kings speech is certain for oscar magic, but andrew roberts says it gets the story all wrong. This website shows spotlight accuracy along with other true. Why it doesnt matter if the kings speech is historically accurate the heart of the story is the relationship between a wouldbe king and his speech pathologist michael lee february. Review of the kings speech as it relates to stuttering.

May 21, 2004 milchs attempt to capture a sense of historical distance with the speech patterns of deadwood succeeds marvelously, but not because the dialogue achieves true realism or gritty accuracy. But, unlike the queen, which was merely simplistic in its portrayal of the monarchy, the kings speech is historically inaccurate, entirely misleading, and, in its own small way, morally dubious. It does show the modern viewer the importance of the treatment given to the king for his speech impediment. This movie was unique in its plot and character development.

But, seemingly that im very weak when it comes to the history of christ and only limited to that i know of islam, im wondering if the movie accurately represents the true story of what had happened. Historical inaccuracies from 11 oscarwinning movies that. The african diaspora, its forgotten historical figures and martin luther kings. Nov 02, 2017 44 of the best historical movies all history buffs need to watch view gallery while documentaries may be the most accurate way to understand history through film, often the best way to capture the true emotional weight of historical events is to portray them dramatically. The kings speech has the potential to join the classics of cinema by being emotionally engaging, historically interesting and socially relevant.

But the play uses an outline of history to expound on. How accurate is the portrayal of king george, more specifically his speech impediment. Dec 20, 2010 the kings speech has the potential to join the classics of cinema by being emotionally engaging, historically interesting and socially relevant. The kings speech is mesmerising, moving and beautifully judged, and cinematically it is right up there with dame judi denchs mrs brown and dame helen mirrens oscarwinning the queen. Its almost wrong to call the kings speech a historical drama, because nearly everything that happens in it is historically accurate. Aug 23, 2017 by movie standards, the film was pretty accurate.

The king s speech cleaned up at the oscars, garnering statuettes for best film, best directing, best original screenplay and lead actor. So thank heavens for the the kings speech, says keith austin, who, like george vi. His brother played by guy pierce was much more convincing as the. Jan 12, 2015 for example, shakespeare s julius caesar isnt exactly historically accurate i. It s also an extremely historically inaccurate film, but that doesnt devalue it as a cinematic achievement.

Hugo vickers, royal adviser on the film the kings speech. Jan 05, 2011 the kings speech is mesmerising, moving and beautifully judged, and cinematically it is right up there with dame judi denchs mrs brown and dame helen mirrens oscarwinning the queen. Braveheart the 10 historical inaccuracies you need to know. The 1995 movie, braveheart, is a cinematic masterpiece. Oct 19, 2015 the kings speech, is based on the incredible trueish story of king george vi, whilst it is not completely historically accurate. The king s speech is a 2010 historical drama film directed by tom hooper and written by david seidler. This movie also captures the real sense of anxiety in britain in the 1930s and it broadly captures the historical context of the coronation of george vi.

The premise behind the kings speech is a rather dry one and the trailers themselves make it seem to be a cross between the madness of king george and pygmalion, but thanks to some winning. Amid colin firths terrific performance as bertie, the duke of york he picked up britains oscar equivalent, a bafta, earlier this month and the movie also won best picture then there were hints that the film was not true to life. Oct 11, 2019 we asked a shakespeare scholar to factcheck the king. Colin firth plays the future king george vi who, to cope with a stammer, sees lionel logue, an australian speech and language therapist played by geoffrey rush. Oscar or not, the kings speech teaches about stuttering. As christopher hitchens points out in slate, winston churchill was a close friend and supporter of nazisympathizer king edward viii george vis brother, who abdicated the throne in order to marry a divorced socialite, leaving george to stutter his way through the. Jan 21, 2012 the king s speech 412 movie clip night cap 2010 hd duration. In the darkest hour movie, winston churchill gary oldman scolds his personal secretary elizabeth layton lily james for hearing him wrong and dictating the incorrect word.

852 1101 1189 570 1095 56 1440 1021 1312 1464 17 671 1205 1122 501 1270 312 265 1193 668 171 285 385 183 123 1066 977 1234 371 1210 1414 1256 864 516 1468 784 712 694 744 723 150 339